Only 48 hours after the federal government refused to be a financial backstop for Lehman Brothers, U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson announces at 9:02 p.m. EST Tuesday evening that the Federal Reserve will take over American International Group (AIG). In exchange for providing an $85 billion bridge loan to the ailing insurance giant, the federal government will receive an unprecedented 79.9% stake in the company.
The Fed’s decision to rescue a private business is nothing short of historic. Previously, Treasury Secretary Paulson had been adamant in saying Wall Street must solve its own problems. With no private-sector support forthcoming for AIG, however - and its potential bankruptcy considered too damaging for the nation’s already battered financial markets - the government had no alternative but to provide a bailout.
Its decision is a costly one. As reported Sept. 16 in the New York Times, AIG initially approached the Federal Reserve and the U.S. Treasury on Sunday, Sept. 14, seeking a $40 billion bridge loan to prevent additional downgrades to its credit ratings. The Fed’s response was a resounding “no.” Two days and two debt downgrades later, the price tag for the bail out went up to $85 billion.
AIG, which is the nation’s biggest insurer, has more than $1 trillion in assets, 74 million clients in 130 countries and 103,000 employees. Its demise potentially could have cost the financial industry $180 billion, according to Bloomberg, in that AIG provides insurance on more than $441 billion of fixed-income investments held by the world’s major institutions, including nearly $60 billion in securities connected to subprime mortgages.
As part of its deal with the federal government, AIG will sell various business assets to repay the $85 billion loan, which is due in 24 months.
In recent weeks, AIG has been caught in a downward financial spiral. With mounting losses on sales of credit default swaps and subprime mortgage-backed securities holdings, the insurer has seen its shares plummet more than 95% this year, closing at less than $4 on Sept. 16. Aggravating AIG’s financial troubles still further was a decision by Moody’s Investors Service and Standard & Poor’s to cut the insurer’s credit ratings on Sept. 15, which required AIG to post billions of dollars of additional collateral for its mortgage derivative contracts - money the insurer was sorely lacking.
Like a number of institutions to falter lately, poor management decisions played a central role in AIG’s financial issues. After two quarters of record losses from overexposure to toxic mortgages, Martin Sullivan, then-CEO, was ousted in June. The company also is the subject of an investigation by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on whether it overvalued the derivatives responsible for more than $20 billion in write-downs.
In 2005, Maurice R. Greenberg, who built the AIG empire and ran the company for nearly 40 years, was forced to retire amid an accounting scandal. The case against him is still pending.
On Sept. 11, 2008, a $115 million settlement was reached in a lawsuit by AIG shareholders against former AIG executives. Specifically, a Louisiana pension fund alleged that hundreds of millions of dollars in commissions were paid by AIG to C.V. Starr & Co., a privately held company controlled by former AIG CEO Maurice Greenberg and other AIG executives.
Now AIG’s current CEO Robert Willumstad is on his way out, and will be replaced by Edward Liddy, former CEO of Allstate Corporation. Under the terms of Willumstad’s contract with AIG, he could receive an exit package worth as much as nearly $9 million.
Meanwhile, American taxpayers now own an 80% stake in yet another company whose failings are the direct result of poor management, lack of corporate governance, and continued bad bets on highly risky investments.
Our affiliation of securities lawyers is actively involved in advising individual and institutional investors in evaluating their legal options when confronted with subprime and other mortgage-related investment losses.